In a November 20, 2026 report, Gamersky said Grand Theft Auto VI had a Metacritic critic score of 99, making it the highest-rated game of 2026 and placing it among the highest-rated games ever. The article questioned why some reviews awarded a perfect score while also describing shortcomings.
Citing a tally by Maki’s Atelier of 72 reviews, the report said 50 mentioned performance issues, 40 criticized the story, 25 raised pacing concerns, and 25 commented on combat or controls. Some reviews that noted problems still gave the game a perfect score.

Maki’s Atelier assigned weights to the reported shortcomings and calculated a hypothetical score of 92.8, compared with an actual review average of 98.6. That calculation reflects Maki’s Atelier’s chosen method, not an alternative published critic score.

Gamersky’s commentary acknowledged that a perfect score need not mean a game has no flaws: reviewers may judge the overall experience exceptional despite specific criticisms. Its question was whether the number alone conveys the reservations expressed in the reviews.




