Former Premier League referee Keith Hackett called for changes to match-official appointments after saying a review panel had recorded six Key Match Incident (KMI) errors across a 10-match round of Premier League fixtures. His comments were reported on 20 November 2026; the account did not identify the specific round of matches.
Hackett said the KMI panel reviews contentious incidents and votes on whether the referee and video assistant referee (VAR) made the correct decisions. He described it as a five-member group comprising three former players or coaches, one Premier League representative and one representative from Pro Ref, formerly PGMOL. He called the number of errors “totally unacceptable” and said the last time that many were announced was in the 2023/24 season.
Hackett argued that VAR should be handled by a specialist group of trained officials working regularly at Stockley Park. He also said Premier League officials should not be assigned to two matches in different roles during the same weekend.
Calling for more detailed reviews with referees and VAR officials, Hackett urged Pro Ref chief Howard Webb to strengthen oversight and take greater care with appointments. He proposed that an official responsible for a KMI error lose at least one subsequent appointment. That is Hackett’s proposed sanction, not a rule reported as being in force.




